Title: A Bond of Brothers Chapter Ten - Words of the Wise Author: Oakenshield (Oakenshield@lonelymountain.zzn.com) Rating: PG-13 Pairing(s): Elladan/Elrohir, implied Celeborn/Haldir Warnings/Spoilers: Incest Archive: Anyone who wants it is welcome to have it, just let me know first. Disclaimer: The characters and the places all belong to J.R.R. Tolkien, and I am making no profit from this at all. Summary: Galadriel and Celeborn have the twins brought to Lothlorien and there they counsel them. ------- Chapter Ten - Words of the Wise Celeborn peered over the railing at the figures climbing the stairs that led to the highest talan in Caras Galadhon. He had observed them for some time, seen them vanish as they turned corners to watch them reappear. He had watched anxiously, nervously, joyously. Three figures walked the long stairway. Two were fair - his guards - the third was dark and frail looking, taking the steps with heavy legs. One twin alone, though his head was bowed too far for Celeborn to see which twin it was. Why were they not together? He would be glad to see either, but even happier to see both. Has something ill befallen one brother? Was that why the other walked with unsteady footsteps? "They are all right, Celeborn." Galadriel came to stand at his side and looked down onto the stairs. "Do not fret so. Only one child may climb our stairs but both are within our realm." He nodded and tried to smile. He had felt it too. Both brothers were safe; if 'safe' was the word. Both brothers were in Lórien, but they were not happy. Sorrow radiated from the one climbing the stairs, and anger from the one who was further away. He was not looking forward to facing either twin but he feared the reaction of one more than the other. "Elladan is going to be furious," he said quietly. Galadriel raised an eyebrow. "Of course he will," she said, laying a hand lightly upon her husband's arm. "He wouldn't be Elladan, otherwise. I for one will be glad to have him shouting before me, just to know that he is before me." Celeborn nodded. "I too," he said, then a worried frown pulled at his mouth. Why was he so afraid of facing Elladan? He had never been *afraid* of his grandson before. Was it really fear? Or was it guilt? Guilt for his part in the twins' downfall, his part in aiding Elrond to deceive them, his part in Haldir's betrayal... He had betrayed them as surely as Haldir and Rúmil had. He had betrayed them, his wife, his daughter and his own honour. He shook his head, wondering why he had been such a fool. How *could* he have been such a fool? The affair he had once had with Haldir had been stale for centuries, how had he allowed himself to be seduced so easily? It was not as if he had even wanted to relive the past, but, simply, Haldir had made him feel strong when he had been weak. He was a father, a grandfather, he should have been strong for his family, not weak and gullible for an old lover! He was the Lord of Lórien, not some slip of an elfling! He knew Haldir had once been in love with him, he knew Haldir was bitter because the love was not returned, that was why he had ended it the first time. He had never wanted to hurt the young marchwarden, he had never expected Haldir to fall so in love with him... He never should have slept with him in the first place, as beautiful as he was. Haldir was young, too young back then. Celeborn had been irresponsible in a way that made him cringe to think of now. He had wanted Haldir for sport, but Haldir had wanted him for love. He hadn't realised that the oaths he had made Haldir swear for his body had been spoken with the young guard's heart. A bit of fun had turned serious and bitter. It was because of him that Haldir had turned serious and bitter. It was because of his rejection that Haldir had wanted Elladan so much. It was because of the hurt he had caused that Haldir had pursued Elladan in the manner he did. So why had he trusted Haldir? Why had he poured his heart out to him? How had he been so weak? Surely Elladan would ask all these questions. That was what he was afraid of. He had already lied to his daughter, and to Elrond. Could he lie to the twins too? The ones who had been most affected by his foolish fling. "They would never forgive me," he whispered, starting a little as he felt Galadriel's hand close around his own. "I forgave you." He looked into his wife's clear eyes. He did not deserve her, not after what he had done. He did not deserve her forgiveness. Though her forgiveness had not come easily. It had been a long time since he and his wife had argued, but after the twins had run away, they had fought all night. He had never felt the stinging blow of her hand to his face, but he had that night. He had never wept until he was hoarse, he had never sunk to his knees to beg for forgiveness, but he had that night. It had been long years since he had made love to his wife, but he had that night. He feared he had broken her heart, but he had not. Could her heart be broken? Did she not love him enough to be crushed by his infidelity? That had hurt more than anything. She had not wept. She had condemned him for betraying the twins, and Celebrían, but she had said nothing of his betrayal to their marriage. She had been angry, and he had been terrified. Not only of her temper, but also of losing her. He realised then, he loved her. He wanted her. He wanted her as he had wanted her when he had first laid eyes on her. He wanted her like he had when they had been young and life had been easier. For a while Haldir had given him back that carefree life, but he wanted it with his wife, not his guard. But what did she want? She had grown so secretive. She was weighed down by troubles she would not share with him. Her heart was overtaken with secrets only she knew and they were consuming her. He wanted to make her laugh again, but how could he when no laughter would come to his own lips? His family was in pieces, and it was his fault. "Do not take all the blame onto your shoulders, Celeborn," she said to him. "The burden is not yours alone." "You are so beautiful, Nerwen," he whispered, clasping her hand. "You are beyond compare to all others. I would ask your forgiveness a thousand times over." "You do not need to," she said with a faint smile. "But we will worry no more about it. It is in the past. We must look to the future now, Celeborn. We must be strong." "My Lord Celeborn." A guard stepped through the door, clearing his throat to announce his presence. "I do beg your pardon, I did not mean to intrude." "Come in, Tinion," Galadriel greeted him. "You are not intruding." "We have Elrohir with us," Tinion replied. "We found him at the borders of Mirkwood, alone. He is not well, and he said little on the journey. Dinendal went on to find Elladan. They are following not far behind, and I believe Elladan is making rather a fuss." "Naturally," Celeborn sighed. "Send Elrohir in please. Then you may be excused." He clasped the guard's shoulder. "Thank you, very much." "My Lord." Tinion bowed politely and stepped out of the door. They got the easy twin first. Celeborn supposed that was a blessing. He did not think he could cope with Elrohir crying and Elladan shouting at the same time. The door opened again, and Elrohir stepped through nervously. Celeborn felt weak at the knees at the sight of him. He was pale and drawn, hunched and shrouded in a fur cloak, with dirt on his face and leaves in his hair. The Prince of Lothlórien had come to this? This could not be Elrohir. This could not be the child who stood tall and straight with gleaming hair, the child who laughed with bright eyes, the sweet, timid and honest younger twin. This could not be him. Yet it was. "Dear Eru," Celeborn whispered softly, staring in disbelief. "What have we done?" Elrohir stood before them with his head lowered, and he visibly trembled as he tried to speak. He looked terrified, like a rabbit stunned in the scent of a stoat. "M- my Lady..." he finally offered, glancing up at Galadriel before tears consumed him and he could speak no more. "Don't you dare 'my Lady' me!" Galadriel hastened towards him and took him in her arms as he all but collapsed into her embrace with ragged sobs. "I am your grandmother, Elrohir. I have not disowned you." She kissed his cheek and squeezed him tightly with tears shining in her eyes. "Oh, I am so thankful that you are safe!" "I am sorry," he whispered as he wept, clinging desperately to his grandmother in a manner Celeborn had not seen since Elrohir had been a child. "I'm so sorry." "Elrohir." Celeborn walked to him and laid a hand between his shoulders. He had to touch him, to prove he was not dreaming. He had dreamed of the boys returning many times, he had dreamed of them half dead, but no dream could compare to the joy and the horror of this reality. "I'm sorry..." Elrohir gasped again, flinching under Celeborn's hand as he turned to look at his grandfather. "Shh, it is all right." Celeborn enveloped him in a hug and held him close. Even beneath fur and cloth, he could feel the sharp edges of shoulder blades and ribs. Elrohir had lost weight. He was frail, and filthy, and Elladan was probably the same, and he could only think that it was all his fault. He should have spoken his mind, he should have stood against Elrond at the start, he should not have told Haldir. It was his fault. Elrohir stuttered on gasping breaths. "I'm sorry for everything," he sobbed hoarsely. "I... I have caused so much trouble, so much pain... I... Oh, I am so sorry..." "Come, Elrohir. Sit down." Galadriel walked to a couch and seated herself. "Am I in awful trouble?" Elrohir whispered fearfully as Celeborn led him by the arm to sit between himself and Galadriel. "I would understand if you wished to punish me after... after everything I have done." "No," Galadriel said, taking hold of his quivering hands. "We only wish to talk to you and your brother. I felt you were fading, Elrohir, and we called the guards out to find you. We only had you brought back here by force because we were scared you were going to die. You have been most unwell, haven't you?" "How did you know where to find us?" he said, then seemed to realise. "Oh, yes, of course. The mirror." He gave a harsh sounding cough. "We didn't want you to find us... we tried not to let you find us, for so long... But I couldn't live like that anymore. I couldn't do it! I had to lift my soul to call out to you, and ai! Elladan will hate me so much for this!" He coughed again. "We thought we were going to lose you!" Celeborn said, offering Elrohir a supporting hand as the coughing buckled him. He had never seen such malady in an Elf. Though their father's mortal blood was surely to blame for that. Had the choice of the Peredhil been revoked in Elrond's rejection? Were the sons of his daughter being forced into mortality? He looked at Elrohir's gaunt face, and tried to catch his eye. Tears were all that shone in the silver orbs. The light that had once made his eyes beautiful was now but a pale glow of sorrow, like a dying candle. "I am all right," Elrohir said, breathing heavily as his coughing ceased. "I am getting better, I think. Do not worry about me, Grandfather." Celeborn leaned to press a kiss to his grandson's forehead. It was still the same selfless Elrohir he had known. "Never do that to me again, Elrohir. Promise me! If you had died, I never would have forgiven myself!" He winced at the harshness of his words as Elrohir's lower lip trembled, but fear and relief hardened his voice, rather than anger. Elrohir sniffed. "I'm sorry..." "Hush." Galadriel took him into her arms again and gently rocked him. "You are safe now, my child. We are going to look after you and make you well again. You have no cause for fear, or for sorrow. Everything is going to be all right." Elrohir looked up at her with wide, wet eyes. "I felt you in my dreams," he whispered. "I felt you calling me home. I want to go home, so badly... But we can't. Elladan won't." "We will see," Celeborn consoled him. "Let us talk to Elladan." Celeborn did not expect Elladan to cooperate, but he would do everything in his power to make things right. He knew he could never hope to make everyone happy, but he would try to make thing as well as they could possibly be. Though he had no idea how he would do this. "Do Mother and Father know we are here?" Elrohir asked, snuggling close to Galadriel's side, relaxing beneath her arm. "No. Nobody does," Galadriel told him, squeezing him gently. "We wanted to talk to you both alone without the rest of the family present. We hoped we could talk to you calmly that way, and take time to sort some things out without any influence from your parents." "I miss Mother terribly." More tears rolled down Elrohir's cheeks, streaking a line through the dirt on his face. "But what about Father? He will not have us back." Celeborn looked at his wife over the top of Elrohir's head and met her thoughts. Now was not the time to talk about Elrond. Elrohir would not be able to stand the torment of knowing his father claimed not to have them as sons. Celeborn did not know how Elrond could say such a thing. He could not condone the incestuous relationship of the twins, but they were still his blood. He still loved them. "I do not know what to do," Elrohir wept. "It is so awful! I cannot make sense of it!" He jumped as the door clattered open, and the bustling sound of a struggle seeped into the room. "Ah, here comes Elladan," Galadriel said calmly as she rose. "Do not let him be angry," Elrohir whispered softly and closed his eyes as he sunk back into the soft upholstery of the couch. Celeborn wished he felt as calm as Galadriel looked as he stood to join her. His stomach was turning over. How would Elladan look? How would he be? How much had he changed? The spiteful creature that had left Imladris on Midsummer's Eve ten years earlier was not the Elladan that Celeborn knew and loved. Had time and hardship made him colder still? Elladan was hurting badly, he could feel it. His eldest grandson always hid pain behind anger. "Curse you, release me this instant!" Elladan shouted as Dinendal shoved him through the door and Celeborn was relieved to see he looked somewhat healthier than his twin did, though just as grubby. "I am not going anywhere now, am I? Undo my bonds!" With a nod from Celeborn, Dinendal untied Elladan and stepped out of the room looking grateful to be rid of his prisoner. Surely, Elladan had not come easily and Dinendal must have had a stressful journey. Before either Celeborn or Galadriel could speak to greet him, Elladan stormed between his grandparents as if they were not there, and stood tall before Elrohir. "You left me!" He looked down at his brother with indignant tears of rage in his eyes, his hands trembling at his sides like he was using all his will to stop himself hitting Elrohir. "I thought I had lost you! Yet you were only a few hours ahead of me on the road, going willingly with Tinion! How could you leave me like that? How could you do that to me! Do you know how afraid I was?!" "You left me," Elrohir whispered, looking up at him with identical tears. "And I did not know Tinion was there until he stopped me. I was heading home anyway." "*You* ran away from *me*, Elrohir!" Elladan cried. "You ran away, you took my horse, and you left me in the middle of the forest, all alone. Did you wish me to die?!" "Did you wish *me* to die?!" Elrohir yelled back at him. "Did you wish my illness to take me?! Or my grief?! I wanted you to follow me. Why didn't you? You thought I would come back, didn't you?" "I hoped you would!" Elladan stamped his foot like a spoiled child, but Celeborn found no amusement in the gesture. "I hoped you loved me enough to stay with me, through anything." "Likewise." Elrohir looked down at his feet again. "Coward." Elladan turned away from him. "You sicken me, as much I love you." "Likewise!" Elrohir shouted as he leapt to his feet. The swift movement nearly sent him crashing to the floor again, but Galadriel quickly darted his side to catch his arm. "Elrohir!" Elladan spun back on his heel, his previous anger at his brother apparently forgotten. "You are still unwell..." Elrohir shook his head. "I am all right," he said shortly, letting Galadriel ease him back onto the couch. "Do not fuss so, Elladan. It is not as if I am dying. Not anymore." Elladan pursed his lips and held his head high but Celeborn could still see tears clinging to the corners of his eyes. The twins had fallen out, badly by the look of things. It was something of a relief to see that they still fought like brothers, though they were lovers. "So what are we doing here?" Elladan demanded, assured that Elrohir was well enough not to have his undivided attention. "Pray, tell me for what means did you have me accosted, bound and all but dragged here?" "Would you have come if Dinendal had not taken such action?" Galadriel countered, sitting beside Elrohir again. "We do not wish to punish you, far from it. We want to help you. We want to talk you, Elladan, so please at least try to be civil." "For my sake," Elrohir whispered, shifting closer to his grandmother. "Please Elladan, hear what they have to say." "Civil?!" Elladan ranted, pacing the floor. "Do tell me how you expect me to be civil! You wish to make things right now? Why did you not feel this way earlier?!" He stopped to look Celeborn in the eyes, then turned back to his grandmother. "You aided my father!" his voice quavered suddenly. "We did not agree with him..." Celeborn began. "You aided him in your cowardly silence!" Elladan flopped to the edge of another couch and put his face into his hands. "If you did not agree, why did you not stand up to him? Why would no one stand up to him? I know we are wrong, but we should not have had to face this alone." Celeborn moved slowly to sit beside him. "Oh, Elladan..." He dared to venture close enough to put his arm around his grandson and was surprised when Elladan leaned heavily into his embrace. The poor child was exhausted. "Please forgive me. I did not want to deceive you, but we could not go against your father's wishes. I know we should have, but you are here now, and Galadriel and I want to do everything we can to make things better. I do not care if you love each other, as long as you are safe, and Galadriel feels the same." "You told Haldir of us." Elrohir looked over at his grandfather with a frown. "Why?" Celeborn had not expected the question to come from Elrohir, and somehow it hurt more. He would have rather felt the question directed with anger rather than hopeless hurt and confusion. "I still do not understand," Elrohir whispered. "My grandfather would not betray me in such a way. I cannot see why you told him everything. Everything. You told him things that Elladan and I did not even know." He wiped the tears from his face with shaking fingers. "I do not understand!" "I thought I could trust him," Celeborn replied feebly. It was a pathetic answer. It wasn't even an answer at all, but he had already given it to Elrond, and to his daughter as she had wept pitifully and begged to know why he had done it. He doubted Celebrían believed it, that he had merely wanted a comforting friend and had turned to Haldir. She was not a fool; she had to know there was more to it than that. He was only thankful that his daughter had not questioned him further. She had been too distraught at her sons leaving to bother about what her father had done. "Well, it seems you were wrong," Elrohir said bitterly. "I have never known you to be a bad judge of character, Grandfather." He stared hard at Celeborn, as if he suspected something, and Celeborn knew he answered his grandson's suspicions when he lowered his eyes to the floor. "Haldir offered an ear and a shoulder," Galadriel said. "Do not blame your grandfather, and do not blame Haldir. Do not lay blame on anyone. No one is wholly guilty that this has come about, and no one is wholly innocent. It is the fault of all. Including myself." "I thought I could trust Haldir too, so I cannot blame you for your mistake." To Celeborn's astonishment, Elladan took the answer. "He is clever with words. As is the brother of his who poured deceit into the ears of the brother of mine." His limbs tensed with anger. "I advise you to keep them away from me. I swear I will kill them both." He looked up at Galadriel. "And I beg your pardon, but I do blame Haldir. I will never forgive him for what he did to us." "I would have them punished, but your grandmother will not hear of it," Celeborn told him. Galadriel did not look on Haldir with anger, even after all he had done. She said he was to be pitied, and so was Rúmil. She said there was more to them than met the eye, but if there was, he could not see it. "They are at the Northern Fences, you will not see them while you are here." "I had better not," Elladan muttered. "If you value their lives." "So," Elrohir sniffed, wrapping his cloak tightly around his body, as if to hide in it. "Surely we are not just here to talk about Haldir and Rúmil? To be frank, I would rather not hear their names at all." "We want to find out what you want, and how we can help you," Celeborn told him. "I know your mother wants you home. Your father..." he sighed. "He will be difficult, but we will cross that bridge when we come to it. We want you to know that you have our support, and if aught goes ill, by your father's will or not there is always a home for the two of you in Caras Galadhon." Elrohir lifted his head and looked at him with wide eyes. "Really?" "That does not mean we approve of your incest," Celeborn added firmly. "I am afraid it is still something we will never understand, and we will certainly not permit you to flaunt it, but it is not something we can change, and we would rather accept it than have you die in the Wild." "So we can stay here?" Elladan asked. "All I want... I want to be with Elrohir. I know no one will ever understand that, but that is all I live for. I want him to be safe, and happy." He smiled at his twin. "I am sorry, my love. I have been selfish." Elrohir smiled back at him. "And I want to be with Elladan," he said. "But I do not want to live like a vagrant anymore. And I miss my mother. I would like to return home, just to see her, to say sorry to her. I would like to see if things could be different. I appreciate that I hope for a lot, but I believe it is worth trying for." "Your father will not be an easy problem to tackle," Galadriel said. "Are you prepared for that?" "I could not care less about him, about any of them," Elladan said coldly and Celeborn shivered at the stark honesty in his words. "Celebrían is not on his side," Galadriel told him. "I think, if you were to return you would have her support. Relationships are torn between her and your father. She wants you back, more than anything. Forgive her. She has forgiven you." Elladan nodded slowly. "I do not know what to do," he sighed. "We tried to make it alone, and we failed, and almost died. But I really do not want to go back to Imladris. I do not want to see Father. I hate him for what he did, for how he tore our family apart, for how he tried to turn so many folk against us." "It is entirely up to the two of you what you choose to do," Galadriel said, "and you can take as long as you like to make a decision, but I really would like you to try again in Imladris. Even if it is just for your mother's sake. I would like to know my daughter is happy again. She has been so sorrowful since you left her." Elrohir rose and walked slowly across the floor to Elladan and crouched before him. "Please?" he said, looking plaintively into his twin's eyes with a look the hardest soul could not have denied. "For me, Elladan. We will be all right this time. We have a bolthole here." Elladan sighed. "All right. I am outnumbered. We will go back to Imladris. I will do this for you," he gave in reluctantly and Celeborn felt sorry to see such a look of defeat on his face. "But do not expect me to be friendly to Father. I can forgive my mother, but I will never forgive him." "So, dare I ask, what about Galadriel and I?" Celeborn said. "Are we forgiven?" "You are." Elrohir rose to kiss his cheek and hugged him. "I cannot believe you want to help us. It means so much." Elladan pulled his brother to sit beside him and took his hand. "I will return to Imladris with you, Elrohir, I will not have you face it alone, as much as I am loath to go back. We will see Mother and Arwen, and then we will come back here. Does that sound fair?" "Yes." Elrohir embraced him tightly. "Thank you so much, Elladan." "I will come with you," Galadriel said. "We both will. We will try to talk some sense into Elrond." "No," Elrohir declined. "We must face this on our own. It is our trouble, and we must take the consequences for it. I do not wish to rock the boat by angering Father towards you." "I can handle your father, Elrohir; I have done so many times in the past, I am not frightened of him," Galadriel said. "Besides, I would very much like to speak to him. There are things I want to discuss that could help things between you and him. It could make him see things differently. Please allow me to." "I do not want to be helped with him," Elladan said coldly. "I want nothing to do with him. It is not important. I do not want to speak to him, and I do not want to stay in Imladris. He says I am not his son. He is not my father. Elrohir and I do not need you to accompany us and hold our hands. We will be fine alone. I want to get it over with as quickly as possible, if I must do it at all." "If you insist," Galadriel sighed, holding up her hands and looking very much like she wanted to argue. Why was she so keen to speak to Elrond, Celeborn wondered. What did she know that could change things so much? "We will provide you with an escort, of course." "Do you not trust us to go alone?" Elladan stiffened. "Do you think we will turn back and run off at the first opportunity?" "We do trust you," Celeborn told him. "But it has been reported there are orcs in great number this winter, especially on Caradhras. I know the two of you can look after yourselves but I would rather not risk it. We have only just got the two of you back here and safe again. Allow us to be a little fussy with you." "It is fine with me," Elrohir agreed. "I agree with Elladan, I want to get it over with as soon as possible. We will wait until the year has turned, it is but a month away, then we will go. If that is well with you?" "It is," Galadriel said, crossing to kiss them both. "And now I will have baths drawn for you!" she laughed, pulling back from them. "You are a little fragrant, to say the least!" ****** Imladris Celebrían quietly opened the door to Arwen's bedroom and peered inside. Her daughter lay cocooned in her covers, fast asleep. Bless the Peredhil for sleeping with closed eyes. She walked quietly across to the bed and placed a gentle kiss on her forehead. "Do not be angry with me," she whispered. "I will bring your brothers home." She pulled her cloak tightly around herself and felt the short sword hanging at her hip. Elrond would miss it in the morning, but not before he would miss her. "Goodbye, my beautiful Evenstar," she whispered and left the room, shutting the door quietly behind her. Keeping close to the shadows, she walked quickly and quietly from the house and into the gardens below. The night was dark and cold, and the first full moon of the New Year glowed in the sky, illuminating her path. She had prayed for the cover of a cloudy night, but it was not to be granted. She had stalled, fearful of the words of the males about orcs, disturbed by Erestor's scars and tales of his torment, but she could stall no longer. She had to find the twins. It had been two months since she had called out to her mother for help, and none had come to her. She had to see her in person. She had to speak to her father, she had to find out the truth about Haldir. She was not afraid anymore. Stealing towards the trees, she froze as an uncomfortable feeling surged down her spine and she turned around to face it. She stared into the darkness of the garden for long seconds. Nothing was behind her... Then a movement at a window in the house above caught her eyes. A movement of golden hair by a curtain. She gasped as her eyes met Glorfindel's from his bedroom window. She had been spotted, and by the worst person possible. Now he would stop her, he would tell Elrond. She could do nothing but stare at him as he stared back at her. Then he gave a small smile, and an understanding nod, and closed his curtains. He had seen nothing. He understood what she was doing, and why she was doing it. He was on her side, for once. Breathing quickly, she walked into the copse of trees where she had ordered ten of the best guards to wait for her. Her horse was saddled there, waiting too. Rather reminiscent of the twins' departure, she thought. Light leather armour was buckled beneath her dress, and she wore leggings and riding boots. The journey was to be hasty. "This is not wise, Bellion," she heard from within the trees. "Lord Elrond will have our hides! He has forbidden her to go. It is not safe." "Which is why I have asked the finest of the Imladris guard to join me," she said to announce her presence. "Fear not for me, Tholinnas," she said. "I will be fine. Look." She showed him her sword. "Are we ready to depart?" "My Lady Celebrían..." he looked like he was about to argue further. "Are we ready to depart?" she repeated. "We are, my Lady," Bellion said. She mounted her horse with determination in her heart. "Then let us go." They were to take the pass of the Redhorn. She was not afraid.