Reviews For The Song of Sunset

Name: Ered Miriwen (Signed) · Date: October 29, 2008 10:01 am · For: Chapter 43. Sacrifices 3

 

...you left me speechless... as usual...

it was an amazing chapter, Eresrtor and Elrond are soo noble, tender and sadly in love, you make their feelings echo into my heart. Galadriel is turning out a great character, strong and defective, but I don't hate her anymore, as I did in the firs chapters. I could carry on talking about the perfection of the plot and the humanity (I know it sounds stupid: they are Elves! but I think you understand what I mean) of the charactersbut I believe I've already written too much.




Name: lovelegollas (Anonymous) · Date: October 29, 2008 03:44 am · For: Chapter 43. Sacrifices 3

Happy that Erestor and Elrond are finally together somehow.

I didn't know that Galadriel sung that tragic song first! You do weaving threads so well, bringing each character in some way to the same point! Glad that Galadreil helped Elrond and Erestor get together...but feel pity for Celebrian and for Gil and for Celeborn too

 

And poor Galadriel, how will she manage to forgive herself? She is alone.

 

Thats the point ; i feel sort of sorry for every character when you write them.. 

  




You must login (register) to review.